Skip to content
Coffee — The Daily Global ConnectionLesson 8 of 17

Fair Trade, Direct Trade, and Commodity

Goal: After this lesson you can tell apart the three coffee sourcing models and what each one means for the farmer. Subject: Economics | Run time: about 7 minutes

Quick recall

Last time we followed one bag of coffee from farm to cup. Two quick questions. One: in the commodity system, about how much of the retail price reaches the farmer? Only about 30 percent, roughly one dollar and twenty cents on a four-dollar bag (Specialty Coffee Association, 2024). Two: what is a supply chain, in plain words? The whole chain of people and steps that move a product from where it is made to where it is used.

Why this matters

You stand in front of two bags of coffee. One says fair trade. One says direct trade. One says nothing special at all. Those labels are not just marketing. Each one is a different deal for the farmer who grew the beans, and the size of that deal can more than double the price they get paid.

The idea

There are three main ways a roaster can buy coffee, and they treat the farmer very differently. Let's take them in order, from worst for the farmer to best. First is commodity coffee, the default, the regular stuff. It is bought and sold on the C-Market, a global market where coffee trades like any other bulk good (International Coffee Organization, 2024). The C-Market runs on volume and price. Nobody on it is asking who grew this or how good it tastes, only how many pounds and how cheap. In that system the farm-gate price sits around a dollar and twenty cents a pound, and the farmer keeps only about 30 percent of the final retail price (Fair Trade USA, 2023; Specialty Coffee Association, 2024). Second is Fair Trade, built to fix the worst problem with the C-Market, the way the price can crash below what it costs to farm. Fair Trade sets a price floor. No matter how low the market falls, a Fair Trade buyer pays at least one dollar and sixty cents a pound, plus another twenty cents a pound as a community premium on top (Fair Trade USA, 2023). That floor is the whole point, a guaranteed minimum the farmer can count on. There is a catch. To sell as Fair Trade, a farm has to be certified, and that certification costs about 2,000 to 4,000 dollars a year (Fair Trade USA, 2023). For a small farm, that is real money to find. Third is direct trade. Here the roaster skips the middle and builds a relationship straight with the farm, usually over several years (Specialty Coffee Association, 2024). Direct trade rewards quality. The beans have to be excellent, scoring high on a professional taste test, and in return the price jumps way up, to somewhere between three dollars and fifty cents and six dollars a pound (Specialty Coffee Association, 2024). Because the price is higher and the chain is shorter, the farmer's share of retail climbs from that 30 percent up to about 30 to 50 percent (Fair Trade USA, 2023; Specialty Coffee Association, 2024). Now the honest part. None of these three is perfect. Commodity pays the least and ignores quality. Fair Trade guarantees a floor but charges the farmer to join. Direct trade pays the most but only works for farms that can hit top quality and find a roaster who wants a long relationship. Each is a different attempt at a hard problem, not a clean fix.

Picture it

Picture three handshakes. In the commodity handshake, the farmer never even meets the buyer. The beans disappear into a giant pile of other beans and a market price decides everything. In the Fair Trade handshake, there is a written promise inside the grip, a floor under the price, but the farmer paid a fee to be in the room. In the direct trade handshake, the farmer and the roaster know each other, shake on it year after year, and the farmer walks away with the fattest envelope of the three.

Remember this

The fact to carry out: three sourcing models pay the farmer very differently. Commodity is volume-driven on the C-Market, about a dollar twenty a pound. Fair Trade guarantees a floor of one dollar and sixty cents plus a twenty cent premium but costs 2,000 to 4,000 dollars a year to certify. Direct trade pays three dollars fifty to six dollars a pound for top quality and lifts the farmer's share to 30 to 50 percent of retail (Fair Trade USA, 2023; Specialty Coffee Association, 2024). None of them is perfect.

Quick check

Quick check. Which model guarantees the farmer a minimum price floor, and what is that floor? Fair Trade, with a floor of one dollar and sixty cents a pound, plus a twenty cent premium on top (Fair Trade USA, 2023).

Key Takeaways

  • Commodity coffee trades on the C-Market by volume and price, paying the farmer about a dollar and twenty cents a pound and roughly 30 percent of retail (International Coffee Organization, 2024; Specialty Coffee Association, 2024).
  • Fair Trade sets a price floor of one dollar and sixty cents a pound plus a twenty cent premium, but certification costs about 2,000 to 4,000 dollars a year (Fair Trade USA, 2023).
  • Direct trade pays three dollars and fifty cents to six dollars a pound for high-quality beans through multi-year relationships (Specialty Coffee Association, 2024).
  • In direct trade the farmer's share of retail rises to about 30 to 50 percent, but none of the three models is a perfect fix (Fair Trade USA, 2023; Specialty Coffee Association, 2024).

Sources

Sign in to track your progress